MLS Duo Toronto FC & CF Montreal Chase Plymouth’s Aribim Pepple — Celtic Monitoring Closely

Aribim Pepple, the towering pillar in Plymouth Argyle’s frontline, has not only captivated the British Isles with his dominant League One performances but has also sparked a fierce bidding war among Major League Soccer (MLS) giants across the pond. 

After a stellar display in the historic 5-2 victory over Cardiff City, racking up 2 goals and 1 assist, the 23-year-old Canadian forward is poised to be the most talked-about "overseas export" of the Summer 2026 window.

MLS Contingent Descends on Home Park

Pepple’s physical superiority and clinical finishing have kept MLS clubs, specifically those seeking a "power and pace" combination upfront, firmly stationed in the Home Park stands.

Pepple’s Canadian passport has ignited a rivalry between CF Montreal and Toronto FC. Leaked intel suggests Toronto scouts have filed reports identifying Pepple as a "next-generation Canadian national team striker." Meanwhile, Montreal views his aerial dominance metrics as among the best in the business.

In addition to long-standing interest from Minnesota United, it has been confirmed that scouts from Vancouver Whitecaps and FC Dallas have been present in the directors' box for the last three home fixtures. Dallas, in particular, aims to position Pepple as the "primary attacking station" in their youth-centric rebuild.

Scottish giants Celtic remain the strongest European candidates, waiting in the wings as the "front-runner." 

From Turkey, Göztepe views the player's dynamism as a perfect "investment project" for the Süper Lig.

A Modern "Target Man" Masterclass

Technical observations in scouting notebooks explain why the demand for Pepple has skyrocketed. 

Standing at 1.85m, Pepple caught the eye against Cardiff by effectively "bullying" opposition defenders to win possession.

A return of 11 goals and 2 assists in 30 matches proves Pepple is not just a physical force but a composed finisher. His near-post runs and one-touch accuracy have earned "elite tier" grades from scouts.

His role as a link-up player in Plymouth’s twin-striker system shows he doesn't just score; he actively involves his teammates in the attacking phase.

Financial Projections and Contractual Deadlock

Plymouth Argyle, having signed Pepple from Luton Town for approximately £250,000 in July 2025, does not view him as a "bargain sale.

The club are understood to value Pepple in the region of £5–7 million, a figure that reflects both his explosive League One impact and growing transatlantic demand.

No official protocol has been signed yet. However, the balance has shifted as MLS clubs disrupt Celtic’s "low-ball" strategy with offers of up-front cash and lucrative salary packages.

Summer 2026 will culminate in the biggest decision of Pepple’s career. 

If he declines a rotational role at a giant like Celtic, the chance to return to North America as one of the "faces of the league" is on the table. 

Analytical data suggests he can adapt to both the physical rigors of the Premier League and the expansive style of MLS. Currently, the MLS "financial siege" looks set to carry Pepple across the Atlantic.