Exclusive: Philadelphia Union Star Makhanya Sparks Transfer Frenzy in Portugal and Italy

The Philadelphia Union’s reputation as a "launchpad" for global talent is about to be reaffirmed. 

Olwethu Makhanya, the 21-year-old South African defensive titan, has officially surged to the top of European scouting shortlists following a stellar 2025 campaign that saw him anchor the Union’s Supporters' Shield-winning backline.

The Scouting Surge: Portugal vs. Italy

The secret is out. Representatives from Europe’s most prestigious talent-hunting circuits have recently been spotted at Subaru Park.

Scouts from Porto and Sporting CP have filed multiple live reports on Makhanya in recent months. The Portuguese giants view him as the perfect "athletic, ball-playing center-back" capable of adapting to the high-intensity tactical demands of the Primeira Liga.

Information has also leaked that Italian clubs Lazio and Fiorentina have prepared comprehensive scouting packages. Italian tactical experts are reportedly impressed by Makhanya’s elite timing and discipline, seeing him as a rare defensive asset who can be refined into a top-tier European starter.

Philadelphia’s "Develop-and-Sell" Model

Philadelphia Union hierarchy has never been afraid to sell at the peak of a player’s value. 

Having recently exercised his contract option through December 2027, the club has secured massive leverage in any upcoming negotiations.

Insiders suggest that Philadelphia has internally set a valuation between €5 million and €7 million ($5.4m - $7.5m). 

While Italian teams are currently in the "monitoring" phase, Portuguese representatives are rumored to be crafting a pre-offer package ahead of the Summer 2026 window to beat the competition.

Analytical Breakdown

Makhanya isn’t just a physical presence; his data profile is elite for his age group. 

An 85% aerial duel success rate, making him one of the most effective defenders in the MLS air space.

Despite his 1.88m (6'2") frame, his long-distance recovery speed allows the Union to play a high defensive line with confidence.

Having started 23 of 29 matches in 2025 and helping secure 14 clean sheets, he has transitioned from a "project" to a "rotation-ready" asset for European top-flight football.

Elsewhere in MLS news, free agent Sergio Ramos has turned down a move to the league. The Real Madrid legend is focusing on a potential takeover of Sevilla and has even offered to play for free in Europe. He has also made his services available to Marseille. Ramos’ illustrious career includes stints at Real Madrid and PSG, and he is Spain’s most-capped player.

Future Scenarios

A move to Portugal is currently viewed as the most logical step for Makhanya’s development, offering a proven pathway to the Champions League. 

However, a move to Serie A could be the higher-ceiling play; the tactical schooling in Italy could potentially transform Makhanya into a €30m+ player within two seasons. 

One thing is certain: Summer 2026 will be the moment Makhanya makes his move across the Atlantic.